Committee Summary for House Criminal Justice and Public Safety (01/22/2025)

Bill/Time	Type	Title	Sponsor
HB194 00:03:57.079 - 9:02:18 AM	Public Hearing	relative to the crime of interference with custody.	Post, Lisa(R)[A]2024
HB257 01:26:35.239 - 10:24:56 AM	Public Hearing	establishing the crime of criminal neglect of a child.	Rollins, Skip(R)[A-]2024
HB405 02:07:11.440 - 11:05:32 AM	Public Hearing	establishing a committee to study approaches to combat store-front sex trafficking in New Hampshire.	Layon, Erica(R)[A]2024
HB416 03:34:20.600 - 12:32:41 PM	Public Hearing	prohibiting the intentional disposal of yard waste into the surface waters of the state.	Rung, Rosemarie(D)[CT]2024
HB191 0035 04:15:15.720 - 1:13:36 PM	Public Hearing	providing criminal and civil penalties for the recruitment, harboring, or transporting of a pregnant, unemancipated minor in order to obtain an abortion without parental permission.	Cordelli, Glenn(R)[A-]2024
HB57 05:44:23.718 - 2:42:44 PM	Public Hearing	relative to a person’s release from prison for the purpose of participating in certain post-secondary education programs in the community.	Meuse, David(D)[CT]2024
HB511 06:04:07.798 - 3:02:28 PM	Public Hearing	relative to cooperation with federal immigration authorities.	Sweeney, Joe(R)[A-]2024

HB194: Representative David Love, Barrington Support00:03:57.079 - 9:02:18 AM; Representative Love, a co-sponsor of HB194, spoke in support of the bill, which aims to amend RSA 633:4 to strengthen penalties for interference with child custody. He highlighted the current issue where law enforcement often misclassifies custody interference as a civil matter rather than enforcing it as a crime. Love emphasized the importance of parental rights and the emotional and psychological well-being of children, urging the committee to support the bill to enforce court orders and protect the bond between parents and children.
HB194: Dana Albert, Nashua Information Only00:08:45.480 - 9:07:06 AM; Dana Albert shared his personal experience as a victim of custody interference, expressing general support for strengthening the law but raising concerns about specific language in the bill. He criticized the inclusion of RSA 173-B, a civil statute, in the criminal context, arguing it could be misused. Albert suggested simplifying the bill to mandate law enforcement to investigate custody interference when probable cause exists, rather than complicating it with potentially problematic language.
HB194: Gail Drat, Amherst Support00:15:06.240 - 9:13:27 AM; Gail Drat supported HB194, emphasizing the need for law enforcement to enforce existing laws on interference with custody. She pointed out that current practices often lead to delays in court, harming children and families. Drat argued that the bill aims to protect children's rights to maintain relationships with both parents and to hold law enforcement accountable for enforcing these laws.
HB194: The Honorable Betty Gay Support00:19:59.080 - 9:18:20 AM; Betty Gay spoke in favor of HB194, discussing the historical reluctance of law enforcement to treat domestic issues as criminal matters. She explained that the bill seeks to clarify that interference with custody is a crime, not a civil matter, and shared examples of parents being denied access to their children despite court orders. Gay emphasized the need for clear enforcement guidelines and penalties to ensure law enforcement takes custody interference seriously.
HB194: Randall Collier Information Only00:30:30.640 - 9:28:51 AM; Randall Collier expressed confusion about his stance on the bill and criticized the legal system's handling of custody cases. He argued that family courts improperly use criminal statutes without evidence and that judges have immunity despite potentially violating constitutional rights. Collier suggested that the committee needs to align bills with constitutional law and shared his personal struggle to see his son, urging for systemic changes to address child custody issues.
HB194: Representative Skip Rollins, representing Unity, Sullivan District 3 Information Only01:02:22.160 - 10:00:43 AM; Representative Skip Rollins introduced the discussion on a case of child neglect in Newport and mentioned that he would not be redundant in his testimony as he had experts present to speak on the issue, including members of the police department, the County attorneys, and a grandmother. He turned the floor over to the next speaker.
HB194: Emily Gad, Strafford County Attorney and Christine Sullivan, Sullivan County Attorney Support01:03:27.599 - 10:01:48 AM; Emily Gad and Christine Sullivan testified in favor of HB27 FN, also known as Charlotte's law, which aims to establish the crime of criminal neglect of a child. Emily Gad, with her extensive experience as a criminal prosecutor, highlighted the limitations of current laws in addressing child neglect and the need for a specific statute to criminalize it. She pointed out the difficulty in charging neglect as assault and the narrow circumstances covered by the endangering the welfare of a child statute. She also discussed a case involving a juvenile sexually abusing his brother and the lack of charges against the father who failed to act. Both attorneys believe the proposed bill would serve as a deterrent and motivate caregivers to comply with safety plans. They addressed questions about religious exemptions and the definition of necessary care, suggesting that these could be managed through jury decisions and potential amendments. They emphasized the need for the statute to address gaps in New Hampshire's child abuse and neglect laws.
HB257: Alex Marvin, Newport Police Department Support01:26:35.239 - 10:24:56 AM; Alex Marvin, a police officer with nearly a decade of experience and currently serving as the commander of the criminal investigations division at the Newport Police Department, testified in support of HB257. He emphasized the vulnerability of children and the critical role law enforcement plays in protecting them. Marvin highlighted the high stakes of child abuse and neglect investigations, noting that improper handling can lead to tragic consequences, including lifelong trauma or death. He discussed the limitations of current statutes which require a 'purposeful' standard for neglect, leaving many cases unaddressed. Marvin argued that HB257 would provide law enforcement with the necessary tools to intervene earlier in neglect cases, preventing harm before it becomes irreversible. He also referenced the Harmony Montgomery case to illustrate broader issues in child protection and mentioned upcoming testimonies from affected individuals to further support the need for legislative change.
HB257: Tina Delorenzo, Claremont, NH Support01:33:58.280 - 10:32:19 AM; Tina Delorenzo, along with her husband Joel, testified in support of HB257, sharing the tragic story of their granddaughter, Charlotte Elizabeth Ward, who died at the age of five due to neglect. Charlotte's death was linked to chronic constipation and a ruptured intestine, which Tina attributed to her mother's negligence and failure to provide necessary medical care. She described the appalling living conditions in Charlotte's home and the lack of legal recourse due to the current 'purposeful' standard for neglect. Tina urged the committee to pass the bill to prevent similar tragedies, emphasizing the need for stronger laws to protect children from neglect and abuse.
HB257: Maryann Lorck Support01:39:21.239 - 10:37:42 AM; Maryann Lorck supported HB257 by recounting the harrowing experience of her granddaughter, Sophia, who was subjected to severe neglect by her father. Sophia was locked in her room, inadequately fed and clothed, and forced to escape her home via a ladder. Despite numerous reports and interventions, the legal system was unable to act decisively due to the existing laws. Maryann highlighted the trauma Sophia endured and the long-term effects she will face, arguing that earlier intervention could have prevented such escalation. She stressed the need for laws that allow for quicker action to protect children from neglect.
HB257: John DeJoy, National Association of Social Workers, NH Chapter Oppose01:44:10.320 - 10:42:31 AM; John DeJoy, representing the National Association of Social Workers, New Hampshire Chapter, opposed HB257. He argued that the bill risks criminalizing poverty, noting that many cases of neglect stem from economic hardship rather than willful neglect. DeJoy also expressed concern that the bill would lead to parents, particularly those with limited means, being ensnared in the criminal justice system without adequate legal representation. He suggested that the issue should be addressed under the child protection act rather than through criminalization and recommended that the committee refer the bill to the children and family law committee for further consideration. He also mentioned ongoing efforts to address gaps in the child protection system.
HB257: Hope Damon, State Representative, Sullivan County Support01:56:06.400 - 10:54:27 AM; Representative Hope Damon, serving half of Sullivan County, spoke as a co-sponsor of HB257. She urged the committee to seriously evaluate the bill's language and intent, emphasizing the need for better protection of children. Damon expressed her belief that including social workers in police departments would significantly enhance meeting families' needs and advocated for better funding and services through DCF to protect children more promptly.
HB405: Representative Erica Layon Rockingham - District 13 Support02:07:11.440 - 11:05:32 AM; Representative Erica Leon from Derry, in her third term, introduced HB405 to address the issue of illicit massage parlors and sex trafficking. She highlighted the lack of tools to deal with these issues under current laws and proposed a study committee to explore effective solutions. Leon mentioned the problem's impact on her town, noting instances where inappropriate touching occurred during massages, and stressed the need for law enforcement to have the necessary tools to address these issues.
HB405: Jody Nelson, State Representative, Derry Support02:12:37.400 - 11:10:58 AM; Representative Jody Nelson from Derry supported HB405, noting that local ordinances have been insufficient in addressing the problem of sex trafficking. She pointed out that businesses are now using different fronts like estheticians and nail salons, and highlighted the dire situation of trafficked women in these establishments. Nelson also mentioned the public health concerns related to unprotected sex acts described in chat rooms and the complicity of some landlords.
HB405: Charles Foot, State Representative, Rockingham County 13, Town Councilor, Derry Support02:17:11.879 - 11:15:32 AM; Representative Charles Foot from Rockingham County 13 and a Derry town councilor supported HB405, discussing the difficulty in addressing the issue locally due to frequent changes in ownership and location of these businesses. He mentioned the proximity of such businesses to town hall and a school, and emphasized the need for state-level action to prevent the problem from shifting to other towns. Foot supported a bill to give teeth to efforts to protect individuals and address complicit landlords.
HB405: Dave Karen, Town Administrator, Derry Support02:19:30.478 - 11:17:51 AM; Dave Karen, the Town Administrator of Derry, supported HB405 and discussed the ineffectiveness of the town's current ordinance in dealing with illicit massage establishments. He suggested improved coordination between state and local levels, enhanced review processes, and stricter licensing to ensure only legitimate businesses operate. Karen also recommended a Statewide database of license applications and employees to aid in tracking these establishments and proposed expanding the study committee to include law enforcement and code enforcement representatives.
HB405: Pamela Kig, Public Policy Specialist, New Hampshire Coalition Against Domestic and Sexual Violence Support02:24:05.080 - 11:22:26 AM; Pamela Kig from the New Hampshire Coalition Against Domestic and Sexual Violence testified in support of HB405, noting the organization's work with victims of human trafficking. She thanked Representative Leon for bringing the bill forward and suggested an amendment, emphasizing the need for action to address the issue effectively. Kig highlighted the committee's unique position to address public safety concerns related to sex trafficking.
HB405: Meg Chant, Director, New Hampshire Human Trafficking Collaborative Task Force Support02:25:33.720 - 11:23:54 AM; Meg Chant, representing the New Hampshire Human Trafficking Collaborative Task Force, provided testimony in support of HB405, emphasizing the need for policy enhancements to combat human trafficking. She detailed the widespread issue of trafficking across all counties in New Hampshire, affecting victims of all ages and nationalities. Chant specifically addressed the challenges with illicit massage businesses, which are fronts for trafficking, and the difficulties in prosecuting these cases due to the lack of victim cooperation and the sophisticated control exerted by traffickers. She highlighted the need for increased penalties and regulatory oversight to effectively address these issues and urged the legislature to take action rather than just study the problem.
HB405: Eric Malera, Task Force Officer, Homeland Security Investigations, Manchester, NH, and Deputy Sheriff, Strafford County Sheriff's Office Support02:35:01.160 - 11:33:22 AM; Eric Malera, a task force officer with Homeland Security Investigations and a deputy sheriff from Strafford County, supported HB405 and emphasized the need for actionable steps over further studies. He discussed the difficulties of investigating illicit massage businesses, which often result in misdemeanor charges, and the need for stricter laws to deter such operations. Malera suggested licensing as a way to legitimize businesses and mentioned the cooperation with local law enforcement and the US Attorney's Office, though proving cases remains challenging.
HB405: Dave McCormack, Task Force Officer, US Department of Homeland Security, and Auxiliary Trooper, New Hampshire State Police Support02:35:15.080 - 11:33:36 AM; Dave McCormack, associated with Homeland Security and the New Hampshire State Police, supported HB405 and echoed the need for immediate action rather than further study. He advocated for stricter licensing and penalties to deter illicit massage businesses, which are often fronts for trafficking. McCormack discussed the complexities of these investigations and the need to view the women involved as victims rather than criminals, emphasizing the need for a multi-state approach to tackle these organized crimes.
HB405: Betty Gay, Citizen Support02:43:47.399 - 11:42:08 AM; Betty Gay, speaking as a citizen, supported HB405 and shared her newfound awareness of the prevalence of prostitution and sex trafficking in small towns, not just large cities. She highlighted the manipulation and control over victims, including children, and stressed the urgency for immediate legislative action to equip law enforcement with necessary tools to combat these crimes. She suggested that while comprehensive laws are needed, immediate amendments to existing laws could provide a quicker response to the issue.
HB416: Rosemary Rung, Representative, Hillsborough 12 (Merrimack) Support03:34:20.600 - 12:32:41 PM; Rosemary Rung, representing Merrimack, introduced HB416, which aims to prohibit the intentional disposal of yard waste into New Hampshire waters to combat toxic cyanobacteria blooms. She explained that while not widespread, this practice contributes to nutrient pollution in lakes, exacerbating the blooms. Rung emphasized the bill's role in fostering lake stewardship and noted its enforcement by peace officers, though she is open to amendments if this aspect is problematic. She highlighted the need for individual responsibility in protecting public resources and the broader efforts required to address environmental issues.
HB416: Murphy Information Only03:43:32.279 - 12:41:53 PM; Murphy discusses the motivation behind sponsoring HB416. He mentions that the bill was inspired by a constituent who was frustrated with the pollution of lakes due to yard waste. Murphy shares a personal observation of an island of leaves floating on a lake, which led him to realize the severity of the issue. He emphasizes the need for individual responsibility to decrease the nitrogen and phosphorus levels in lakes, which contribute to blooms. He also points out that the law aims to increase awareness among both New Hampshire residents and seasonal visitors about what is permissible in lake areas.
HB416: Bria Arbeton, Director of Programs, New Hampshire Lakes Support03:48:15.640 - 12:46:36 PM; Bria Arbeton from New Hampshire Lakes supports the intent of HB416 to prohibit the disposal of yard waste in state waters. She acknowledges that yard waste dumping does occur and contributes to lake pollution, although she defers to others for specific evidence linking yard waste to algae blooms. Arbeton emphasizes the role of Lake Associations in educating the public and suggests that neighborly conversations can help enforce the law.
HB416: Ted Deers, Assistant Director, Water Division, New Hampshire Department of Environmental Services Information Only03:52:00.680 - 12:50:21 PM; Ted Deers explains that the disposal of yard waste in lakes is already illegal under existing state law (RSA 485-A:15). However, he acknowledges that the language of the current statute may not be clear to modern audiences. Deers discusses the challenges in enforcement due to limited staff and relies on public complaints to address violations. He suggests that HB416 could be improved by clarifying its placement within state law and expresses willingness to work with the bill's sponsor on potential amendments.
HB416: Dave Neils, Head of Watershed Management Bureau, New Hampshire Department of Environmental Services Information Only03:52:00.680 - 12:50:21 PM; Dave Neils, a lake ecologist, discusses the impact of cyanobacteria on recreational activities like fishing for largemouth bass. He highlights the issue of invasive species like the spiny water flea, which can promote cyanobacteria by disrupting the food web. Neils also mentions the rising temperatures of lakes and the delayed ice-in and early ice-out dates, contributing to environmental changes.
HB416: Representative Murphy Information Only04:02:38.199 - 1:00:59 PM; Representative Murphy discusses the public health concerns related to cyanobacteria exposure, citing research by Dr. Stoll at Dartmouth on the association with ALS. He questions the placement of the bill within existing statutes, suggesting it may be better suited elsewhere but acknowledges it would not cause harm if passed as is.
HB416: Representative Lascell Information Only04:04:57.159 - 1:03:18 PM; Representative Lascell inquires about the enforcement capabilities of the Fish and Game Department regarding yard waste disposal in lakes. Ted Deers responds that while Fish and Game might report issues, enforcement typically falls under DES statutes. He highlights that the bill allows any peace officer to enforce it, potentially including municipal and state law enforcement.
HB416: Representative Umuse Information Only04:07:18.080 - 1:05:39 PM; Representative Umuse questions whether the enforcement provisions for sewage disposal from boats could provide guidance for enforcing HB416. Ted Deers agrees that looking at similar statutes could be helpful in refining the enforcement approach for the bill.
HB416: Representative Sourdough Information Only04:08:03.199 - 1:06:24 PM; Representative Sourdough asks about natural predators of the invasive spiny water flea and the possibility of chemical solutions to address cyanobacteria blooms. Dave Neils indicates that fish occasionally eat the fleas but there are no effective chemical solutions to reduce nutrients causing blooms.
HB191 0035: Glenn Cordelli, Representative, Tuftonboro, Wolfeboro, and Alton Support04:15:15.720 - 1:13:36 PM; Glenn Cordelli presents HB191, aimed at protecting minor girls from predators and sex traffickers by criminalizing adults who transport or procure abortion-inducing drugs for unemancipated minors without parental consent. He highlights the growing problem of human trafficking in New Hampshire, citing statistics and a recent case. Cordelli discusses the amendment to the bill, clarifying its intent and scope, and expresses openness to further refinement to address concerns about its breadth and potential misuse.
HB191 0035: Representative Roy Information Only04:25:24.880 - 1:23:45 PM; Representative Roy questions whether HB191 would also apply to an adult male in an inappropriate relationship with a minor who seeks an abortion to cover up evidence of statutory rape. Cordelli confirms that the bill would apply in such cases.
HB191 0035: Representative Sher Information Only04:26:11.000 - 1:24:32 PM; Representative Sher raises concerns about the bill's broad application, distinguishing between sex trafficking cases and other situations involving minors. Cordelli confirms that the bill applies to any adult taking a minor for an abortion without parental consent, though he acknowledges a lack of specific data on such occurrences in New Hampshire outside of trafficking cases.
HB191 0035: Representative New Information Only04:29:51.479 - 1:28:12 PM; Representative New questions the requirement for notarized parental consent and the potential for misuse by biological fathers in civil actions. Cordelli suggests that courts would consider the full context, including non-notarized written consent, if parents maintain their consent.
HB191 0035: Representative Murray Information Only04:32:14.040 - 1:30:35 PM; Representative Murray inquires about Cordelli's stance on removing the notarization requirement for parental consent, citing it as a potential barrier. Cordelli expresses neutrality on the issue, open to amendments as the bill progresses.
HB191 0035: Representative Pratt Information Only04:33:44.438 - 1:32:05 PM; Representative Pratt questions who would enforce the bill and what would happen if a minor drove herself across state lines for an abortion. Cordelli clarifies that the bill targets adults accompanying minors and would not apply if the minor goes alone.
HB191 0035: Phillips Oppose04:35:05.879 - 1:33:26 PM; Phillips spoke in opposition to HB 1191 as amended, arguing that it is unenforceable, unconstitutional, and politically unviable. They expressed concerns that the bill would lead to a climate of government surveillance and questioned how law enforcement would implement it, suggesting possibilities like random pregnancy tests and inspections of healthcare facilities. They argued that the bill would invade the privacy of young people, infringe upon their rights to travel and bodily autonomy, and shift the power of reproductive decision-making to parents, which could be harmful in cases of abuse or incest. Phillips also highlighted potential political damage from the bill, noting the governor's stance against further abortion restrictions and suggesting that it would cause internal party conflict.
HB191 0035: Jason Hennessy, President for New Hampshire Right to Life Support04:39:42.000 - 1:38:03 PM; Jason Hennessy, representing New Hampshire Right to Life, spoke in enthusiastic support of HB 1191. He cited a story of a girl involved in forced prostitution and multiple abortions to illustrate the need for the bill, emphasizing its role in protecting minors from trafficking and abuse. Hennessy argued that the bill requires parental involvement in a minor's abortion decision, addressing the issue of abortion pills available online. He mentioned the sex trafficking problem in New Hampshire, citing statistics and a case of abuse under state protection. He addressed concerns about the bill's constitutionality and its focus on behavior within the state, clarifying that the bill targets adults who assist minors in obtaining abortions without parental consent or judicial bypass.
HB191 0035: Hannah Eliason, resident of Hopkinton, New Hampshire Oppose05:01:08.958 - 1:59:29 PM; Hannah Eliason, a resident of Hopkinton, New Hampshire, spoke in opposition to HB 1191, arguing that the bill is about controlling children's, specifically girls', bodies rather than addressing sex trafficking. She warned of a slippery slope toward authoritarianism, drawing historical parallels to Nazi Germany's destruction of the Institute for Sexual Science. Eliason highlighted the presence of hate groups in New Hampshire and criticized the bill for not aligning with the state's motto of 'Live Free or Die.' She expressed concerns that the bill would increase teen pregnancy rates and emphasized that reproductive decisions should be made between the child, their parents, and their doctor, not legislated by men. She also drew parallels between the bill's language and that of the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850, urging the committee not to set a harmful precedent in New Hampshire.
HB191 0035: Rebecca Leak, resident of Andover, New Hampshire Support05:06:35.840 - 2:04:56 PM; Rebecca Leak testified in favor of HB191, emphasizing that the bill criminalizes taking a minor to obtain an abortion without parental consent. She highlighted the importance of the bill in preventing traffickers and abusers from using abortions to cover up their crimes. Leak mentioned that abortion facilities often fail to report child sexual abuse, and this law would help protect vulnerable young women and girls from such abuses. She urged the committee to recommend that HB191 ought to pass.
HB191 0035: Jesse Heath Vincent, resident of New Hampshire Oppose05:07:51.240 - 2:06:12 PM; Jesse Heath Vincent opposed HB191, arguing that it imposes criminal penalties on those assisting minors in obtaining abortions without parental approval, which he considers punitive and unnecessary. He expressed concern that the bill could harm the well-being of vulnerable minors and noted that RSA 132 already offers a balanced framework for addressing these issues. Vincent suggested that strengthening RSA 132 would be a better approach than advancing HB191. He urged the committee to reject the bill and work on bipartisan solutions that protect minors and uphold bodily autonomy.
HB191 0035: Barbara Patch, resident of New Hampshire, Director of All Girls Alloud Incorporated, and representative of the New Hampshire Traffic Free Coalition Support05:11:44.760 - 2:10:05 PM; Barbara Patch supported HB191, focusing on its potential to help identify and stop sex traffickers. She clarified that the bill is necessary because sex trafficking is difficult to detect and prosecute. Patch cited a 2023 study showing that 65% of sex trafficking survivors had at least one abortion, illustrating the exploitation faced by these victims. She emphasized the need for the bill to raise red flags and initiate criminal proceedings against traffickers. Patch also suggested considering measures to provide support services and alternatives like adoption for victims.
HB191 0035: Dr. Cynthia Rasmussen, resident of New Hampshire, retired obstetrician-gynecologist Oppose05:23:46.360 - 2:22:07 PM; Dr. Cynthia Rasmussen expressed concern about HB191, sharing her experience with a high school education professional who reported an increase in unintended pregnancies among young girls. She highlighted the challenges faced by the one-third of pregnant teens who do not disclose to their parents, often due to fear of violence or being forced to continue the pregnancy. Rasmussen argued that the bill would make abortion access more difficult for vulnerable teens, potentially leading to negative health outcomes and increased risks. She urged the committee not to support the bill, suggesting that addressing root causes of teen pregnancy would be more effective.
HB191 0035: Kath Stratton, speaking on behalf of the Medical Society of New Hampshire Oppose05:30:44.798 - 2:29:05 PM; Kath Stratton opposed HB191, expressing concern that the bill would impact access to appropriate medical care for minors and potentially remove physicians as a trusted resource for those being trafficked. She argued that the bill does not address the core issue of trafficking and might lead to minors seeking unsafe medical procedures. Stratton urged the committee not to support the bill, emphasizing the need to maintain safe and accessible medical care for young women.
HB191 0035: Courtney Reid, Policy Advocate for the ACLU New Hampshire Oppose05:33:32.600 - 2:31:53 PM; Courtney Reid testified against HB191, highlighting constitutional threats posed by the bill. She discussed concerns about freedom of speech and expression due to the bill's vague language on harboring and transporting. Reid also raised issues with due process, suggesting the bill's ambiguity could lead to unfair treatment under the law. She pointed out potential violations of the right to travel and privacy, especially with the requirement for notarized parental consent. Reid urged the committee to reject the bill, emphasizing its potential to increase government interference in private lives.
HB191 0035: Kayla Montgomery, resident of New Hampshire Information Only05:40:02.558 - 2:38:23 PM; Kayla Montgomery's testimony was cut short due to the length of the hearing, and she intended to be brief. No further details were provided in the transcript.
HB191 0035: Kayla Montgomery, Vice President of Public Affairs for Planned Parenthood New Hampshire Action Fund and PPN Information Only05:40:10.440 - 2:38:31 PM; Kayla Montgomery, representing Planned Parenthood, discussed the existing parental notification law in New Hampshire, which has been in effect for over a decade. She emphasized that most teenagers already involve their parents in decisions regarding pregnancy, but the law requires parental notification. Montgomery explained that Planned Parenthood and other abortion providers comply with this law, as outlined in RSA 132 sections 32 through 36, which provides clear guidelines on how to meet these legal requirements. She highlighted exceptions such as medical emergencies and judicial bypass, which are rare. Additionally, she addressed the issue of coercion, stating that Planned Parenthood has thorough procedures to ensure no one is coerced into an abortion, emphasizing the priority of individualized care and patient comfort.
HB57: Representative David Muse, Rockingham District 37, representing Portsmouth, Newington, and Newcastle Support05:44:23.718 - 2:42:44 PM; Representative David Muse introduced HB57, which aims to allow individuals under the control of the Department of Corrections and approved for administrative home confinement to participate in postsecondary educational opportunities in the community. He explained that current laws permit such individuals to engage in employment and public service, but this bill would extend that to include attending college courses. Muse clarified that the bill does not change eligibility or the process of administrative home confinement, and inmates or their families would be responsible for the costs of education, not the state. He cited studies showing reduced recidivism and increased employment rates for inmates who participate in college programs, emphasizing the tangible benefits of the legislation.
HB57: Nick Duffy, Director of Rehabilitative Services for the New Hampshire Department of Corrections Support05:49:05.120 - 2:47:26 PM; Nick Duffy testified in support of HB57, highlighting the importance of education in reducing recidivism. He explained that the Department of Corrections conducts a thorough review before approving individuals for administrative home confinement, which includes housing, financial support, and treatment plans. Duffy confirmed that the bill would allow inmates to engage in higher education opportunities, aligning with the department's goal to ensure successful reintegration into society. He addressed questions about the definition of postsecondary education, affirming that it would include trade schools and internships, as long as they are accredited.
HB57: Claudia Stelle, Adjunct at River Valley Community College, Alworth Support05:59:26.040 - 2:57:47 PM; Claudia Stelle, an adjunct at River Valley Community College, spoke in favor of HB57. She shared her experience teaching remedial math to students of various ages, including a young man who had been involved with the judicial system. Stelle emphasized the importance of education in building confidence and skills, particularly for those trying to overcome past challenges. She supported the bill as it would provide more individuals the opportunity to better themselves through education, potentially reducing recidivism. Stelle also discussed the delivery of her classes, which are primarily in-person at the Keene campus, and expressed her belief in the value of personal interaction in education.
HB511: Prime Sponsor, House Bill 511 Support06:04:07.798 - 3:02:28 PM; The prime sponsor introduced HB511, which aims to strengthen public safety and uphold the rule of law by addressing cooperation between local, state, and federal law enforcement on immigration matters. The bill prohibits state and local entities from adopting sanctuary policies, mandates cooperation with federal immigration authorities, and creates an enforcement mechanism through the Attorney General. The sponsor clarified that the bill does not require local law enforcement to act as immigration officers but ensures that state and local agencies do not obstruct federal immigration enforcement. The sponsor emphasized the importance of this legislation for community safety and law enforcement collaboration, urging support for the bill.
HB511: Representative Muse Information Only06:08:31.920 - 3:06:52 PM; Representative Muse responded to questions about the implementation of HB511. They clarified that the bill does not direct local New Hampshire law enforcement to become immigration enforcers but rather to cooperate with ICE. They noted that law enforcement would not proactively seek undocumented individuals but would work with ICE when individuals are arrested for other crimes. Muse also addressed a suggestion to amend the bill's language from 'person' to 'inmate' to narrow its scope, stating they would not oppose this change. They discussed the potential impact of the Laken Riley Act on the bill, suggesting that any new federal laws would require New Hampshire law enforcement to work with federal immigration officials. Lastly, they expressed their belief that more enforcement at the borders could help reduce human trafficking.
HB511: Mary Jores, Manchester Oppose06:18:10.680 - 3:16:31 PM; Mary Jores, a resident of Manchester, shared her personal story as an immigrant from the Democratic Republic of Congo. She described arriving in the U.S. in 1990 and facing challenges due to her undocumented status. Jores emphasized her hard work and contributions to the community, including becoming a U.S. citizen, obtaining multiple degrees, and serving as a state representative and school board member. She opposed HB511, arguing that immigrants contribute significantly to society and should not be penalized for their status. Jores highlighted the difficulties faced by undocumented immigrants and stressed the importance of compassion and understanding in immigration policy.
HB511: Janine Nader, Marlow Support06:27:35.280 - 3:25:56 PM; Janine Nader from Marlow expressed strong support for HB511. She emphasized the importance of enforcing immigration laws and protecting national borders. Nader shared her experiences visiting the U.S.-Mexico border and witnessing issues such as drug smuggling and human trafficking. She argued that the bill is necessary to address these problems and ensure the safety of New Hampshire residents. Nader stressed that the bill is not about punishing families but about addressing unknown individuals crossing the border illegally.
HB511: Yil Binet, ACLU of New Hampshire Oppose06:29:53.120 - 3:28:14 PM; Yil Binet, the legal director at the ACLU of New Hampshire, testified in opposition to HB511. They argued that the bill's language is broad and could mandate local police to perform federal immigration enforcement, which they believe is inappropriate. Binet highlighted concerns about the bill's requirement for compliance with immigration detainers, noting that detainers are requests and not mandatory. They also pointed out constitutional issues with detaining individuals for civil immigration violations and expressed concerns that such mandates could deter immigrants from seeking police assistance. Binet suggested that an amendment proposed last year was more palatable but still had issues with detainer compliance.
HB511: Kevin Moore, Upper Valley Oppose06:44:17.760 - 3:42:38 PM; Kevin Moore, a volunteer from the Upper Valley, opposed HB511. He spoke about his experiences at a homeless shelter in Vermont and emphasized the humanity of immigrants. Moore argued that the bill would punish and jail people who are seeking freedom and should be treated as brothers and sisters. He urged the committee to consider the impact of the bill on human lives and to reject measures that would lead to incarceration of undocumented individuals.
HB511: Sher Randall Support06:45:21.478 - 3:43:42 PM; Sher Randall testified in strong support of HB511 on behalf of the Federation for American Immigration. They did not provide further details in the provided transcript snippet.
HB511: Sherry Rendle, Director of State and Local Engagement, Organization for Immigration Reform Support06:45:47.600 - 3:44:08 PM; Sherry Rendle, representing the Organization for Immigration Reform, testified in support of HB511. She emphasized the need for immigration law reform and highlighted the dangers of sanctuary policies, which she argues allow illegal aliens to live and work without fear of apprehension. Rendle pointed out that individuals entering the country illegally or overstaying visas have not been vetted, posing unknown risks, including those on terrorist watch lists encountered at borders. She listed several New Hampshire towns and counties (Chester, Deerfield, Dublin, Durham, Hanover, Harrisonville, Lebanon, Lime, and Manchester) as effectively functioning as sanctuary cities despite not officially labeling themselves as such. She also discussed the impact of sanctuary policies on crime reporting and the use of detainers by various law enforcement agencies, arguing that not honoring immigration detainers could lead to increased risks to public safety.
HB511: Eva Costello, Manchester Oppose06:51:18.558 - 3:49:39 PM; Eva Costello from Manchester testified in opposition to HB511. She argued that the bill would undermine the trust built between immigrant communities and law enforcement, which is crucial for community safety. Costello stated that current collaboration between police and ICE is sufficient, and that police should not be burdened with enforcing federal immigration laws, as they are already tasked with numerous other responsibilities. She emphasized that no human being is illegal and that the bill would not enhance community safety.
HB511: Christine Wellington, Derry, New Hampshire Immigrants Rights Network Oppose06:53:38.440 - 3:51:59 PM; Christine Wellington from Derry and a member of the New Hampshire Immigrants Rights Network opposed HB511. She stressed that the bill prioritizes civil immigration enforcement over the interests of the communities served by local and state police. Wellington explained that the detainers mentioned in the bill are civil and not criminal, and are processed through administrative courts. She expressed concern that the 'best efforts' clause in the bill could remove necessary discretion from law enforcement, potentially affecting victims or witnesses eligible for certain visas. She also highlighted the potential liability risks to officers if the bill were to pass, as the federal government would not cover these costs.
HB511: Bob Dunn, Director of Public Policy, Roman Catholic Diocese of Manchester Oppose06:55:43.718 - 3:54:04 PM; Bob Dunn, speaking on behalf of Bishop Peter Labashi from the Roman Catholic Diocese of Manchester, opposed HB511. He argued that the bill, intended as a public safety measure, was not supported by the Department of Safety or the New Hampshire Chiefs of Police, who are typically proactive in suggesting legislation for public safety. Dunn emphasized the importance of the discretion currently exercised by police chiefs in handling detainers, which he believes is crucial for maintaining trust and communication with communities, thereby ensuring crimes are reported. He suggested that this discretion, which would be removed by the bill, is necessary for effective public safety.

Roy, Terry(Chairman)(R)[B]2024	Murray, Alissandra(Clerk)(D)[D-]2024	Rhodes, Jennifer(V Chairman)(R)[B]2024
Harriott-Gathright, Linda(D)[CT]2024	Proulx, Mark(R)[B]2024	Lascelles, Richard(R)[B+]2024
Morency, Pete(R)	Paquette, Kathleen(R)	Murphy, Nancy(D)[CT]2024
Newman, Ray(D)[CT]2024	Meuse, David(D)[CT]2024	Devoid, Ricky(R)
Newell, Jodi(D)[D-]2024	Scherr, Buzz(D)	Valerino, Brian(R)
Sabourin dit Choinière, Matt(R)